





September 19, 2026
Choosing Your Defense Attorney Can a language barrier be used as a defense when a person is asked to submit to a blood draw during a DUI investigation in Pennsylvania?
The answer, like many questions in criminal defense, is: maybe. It depends on the specific facts and circumstances of the case.
Table of Contents
Toggle
During a DUI investigation, police may rely on several observations and investigative steps to determine whether they believe a driver is impaired. Depending on the circumstances, an officer may ultimately request that the individual submit to chemical testing, including a blood draw. When a person does not speak or fully understand English, however, an important question can arise: Did the individual actually understand what the officer was requesting and the potential consequences of refusing?
SKA Law Group has handled cases in both Pennsylvania and New Jersey where a language barrier became an important issue when reviewing an alleged refusal. The defense may examine whether officers took reasonable steps to communicate with the individual and whether the evidence demonstrates that the person actually understood what was being explained.
Body-camera footage, police reports, audio recordings, interpreter services, and the individual’s responses and conduct can all become important evidence. If the evidence indicates that the person did not understand what was being requested or the consequences associated with refusing chemical testing, the language barrier may become a significant issue when evaluating the case.
In Pennsylvania, a refusal can also have consequences involving PennDOT that are separate from the underlying criminal DUI prosecution. Because the criminal case and driver’s-license consequences can involve different legal standards and procedures, each must be evaluated independently.
Every DUI case is fact-specific. A language barrier does not automatically invalidate a refusal or result in dismissal of a DUI charge, but it can be an important factor for a defense attorney to investigate when reviewing the totality of the circumstances.
This article is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not legal advice, does not create an attorney-client relationship, and does not guarantee any particular result. Every case depends upon its individual facts and applicable law.
Montgomery 12/2016

